Vol. 80; No. 21; September 15, 2004
One-year's trial subscription1/2
price!!
EDITORIAL POLICY
Every editor is solely responsible
for the contents of his own articles. Contributions of general interest from our readers
and questions for "The Reader Asks" department are
welcome. Contributions will be
limited to approximately 300 words and must be neatly written or typewritten, and must be
signed. Copy deadlines are the first and fifteenth of the month. All communications
relative to the contents should be sent to the editorial office.
REPRINT POLICY
Permission
is hereby granted for the reprinting of articles in our magazine by other publications,
provided: a) that such reprinted articles are reproduced in full; b) that proper
acknowledgment is made; c) that a copy of the periodical in which such reprint appears is
sent to our editorial office.
SUBSCRIPTION POLICY
Subscription
price: $17.00 per year in the US., US $20.00 elsewhere. Unless a definite request for
discontinuance is received, it is assumed that the subscriber wishes the subscription to
continue, and he will be billed for renewal. If you have a change of address, please
notify the Business Office as early as possible in order to avoid the inconvenience of
interrupted delivery. Include your Zip or Postal Code.
BOUND VOLUMES
The
Business Office will accept standing orders for bound copies of the current volume. Such
orders are mailed as soon as possible after completion of a volume year.
l6mm microfilm, 35mm microfilm and 105mm
microfiche, and article copies are available through University Microfilms international.
For new subscribers in the United States to the Standard Bearer, there is a special offer: a ½ price subscription for one year--$8.50. Those in other countries can write for special rates as well to: The Standard Bearer, P.O. Box 603, Grandville, MI 49468-0603 or e-mail Mr. Don Doezema.
Each issue of the Standard Bearer is available on cassette tape for those who are blind, or who for some other reason would like to be able to listen to a reading of the SB. This is an excellent ministry of the Evangelism Society of the Southeast Protestant Reformed Church. The reader is Ken Rietema of Southeast Church. Anyone desiring this service regularly should write:
Southeast PRC
1535 Cambridge Ave. S.E.
Grand Rapids, MI 49506.
Table of Contents:
Meditation - Rev. Rodney Miersma
Editorial - Prof. David J. Engelsma
Review Article - Prof. David J. Engelsma
Taking Heed to the Doctrine - Rev. James Laning
All Around Us - Rev. Kenneth Koole
Book Reviews:
News From Our Churches Mr. Benjamin Wigger
Rev. Miersma is a missionary of the Protestant Reformed Churches, currently serving in Ghana, West Africa.
And other sheep I have, which are not of this fold: them also I must bring, and they shall hear my voice; and there shall be one fold, and one shepherd. John 10:16
Other sheep I have which are not of this fold. Notice that the text twice uses the word fold. The Revised Version translates the text using that word only once. It reads, Other sheep I have which are not of this fold: them also I must bring, and there shall be one flock and one shepherd. In this instance the latter is better. These sheep are not of the same fold, but they will be one flock. The point is important. The fold was the place where the sheep were kept, enclosures in the open country where the shepherds of the Orient herded their flocks at night. This fold, therefore, refers to the old dispensation; the Jewish theocracy; the people out of which Christ Himself was, historically; the natural seed of Abraham; national Israel. The other sheep are not of this fold. They are, therefore, the elect that are not out of the natural seed of Abraham. They are the elect of the new dispensation, of the Gentile nations, referred to in so many Old Testament prophecies. In those days it shall come to pass, that ten men shall take hold out of all languages of the nations, even shall take hold of the skirt of him that is a Jew, saying, We will go with you: for we have heard that God is with you, (Zech. 8:23). Those are the other sheep.
Them also I must bring, says Jesus. His final sufferings and death and resurrection and ascension and redemptive work throughout the new dispensation still lay ahead. These sheep, therefore, and they only, are the objects of the bringing. They only are the objects of the bringing in the intentions of God. Always God reveals Himself as willing only to those whom He Himself has sovereignly ordained unto eternal life. They only are the objects of the bringing in the intentions of the Christ. I came down from heaven, not to do mine own will, but the will of him that sent me. And this is the Fathers will which hath sent me, that of all which he hath given me I should lose nothing, but should raise it up again at the last day (John 6:38, 39). And even as these sheep, and they only, are the objects of the bringing in the purposes of the Most High and His Christ, thus they, and they only, are actually saved. Them also I must bring.
This assures us, and all who labor in the gospel, that, regardless of apparent futility, our work is never in vain in the Lord. The work of the gospel often seems so fruitless, like a plowing on rocks. Never fear, God is accomplishing all His good pleasure. This leaves God GOD, out of whom and through whom and unto whom are all things. And this preaches a Christ who actually brings to pass all He came to do.
There is a slogan that reads, Christ saves to the uttermost. That is as true as true can be, if only we understand it to mean: Christ saves all He came to save. Our Canons of Dordt state it so beautifully in Head 2, Article 9: This purpose, proceeding from everlasting love towards the elect, has from the beginning of the world to this day been powerfully accomplished, and will henceforward still continue to be accomplished, notwithstanding all the ineffectual opposition of the gates of hell.
Them also I must bring. The Son of God is speaking here. John, more than all the others, emphasizes the deity of Christ. It is in the sublime consciousness that He is the only begotten Son, and therefore Himself God, that Christ speaks throughout this chapter. I am the door of the sheep I am the good shepherd . As the Father knoweth me so know I the Father I give unto them eternal life I and my Father are one. So well do the wicked Jews understand Him, that they want to stone Him, because, say they, Thou makest thyself God. As the Son of God He speaks in our text: Other sheep I have them also I must bring and they shall hear my voice. The Son of God alone must bring the sheep if brought they shall be.
As the Good Shepherd, Jesus stands in contrast to the evil shepherds referred to in Scripture. They fed themselves instead of the sheep. They ate the fat, clothed themselves with the wool, but fed not the flock. They strengthened not the diseased, healed not the sick, sought not the lost. They enter by another way than the door, to kill and to steal and to destroy. They flee when the wolf comes because the sheep are not their own. These are the evil shepherds at whose hands the flock will be required. Jesus is the Good Shepherd. He feeds the flock; He strengthens the diseased; He enters by the door; He calls the sheep by name; He leads them forth; He gives His life for the sheep. And thus, as the Good Shepherd, the Son of God is in deep reality the only missionary.
True, it pleases Him to use human preachers and missionaries as His instruments. These have the calling to preach the gospel of salvation to all creatures, beginning at Jerusalem and thence to the ends of the earth. With such mission work we agree with all our hearts. Mission work aims to proclaim the blessed gospel of Christ to all creatures. Even so, in truth Christ is the only missionary. We do not win the souls for Jesus. We preach Christ crucified. Christ, through that preaching, wins His own souls. Them also I must bring.
Literally, this word bring means to drive or to lead. It means to lead by laying hold of, so that the basic idea of the word includes the notion of determination and power on the part of Him who does the bringing. It refers, therefore, to all that the Good Shepherd does to bring the sheep to salvation, actually, efficaciously, irresistibly.
To this bringing belongs all Jesus does for us in the fullness of time. Remember, we wrote at the beginning of this article that His final sufferings and death, resurrection and ascension, outpouring of the Spirit and redemptive work throughout the ages still lay ahead when He uttered these words. The Good Shepherd is thinking of all these. He suffers and dies, pays the penalty of sin and removes the guilt, reconciles with the living God, and merits the right to eternal life.
All this He does for His own. Limited atonement! I lay down my life for my sheep. Then He rises from the dead and is exalted on the right hand of God, and there He receives all power and authority over all things and the Spirit without measure to bless His own with every spiritual blessing in heaven. Them also I must bring includes all this.
Subjectively, this bringing to salvation is realized in all that the Good Shepherd does in us. He calls by the preaching of His Word. Therein He speaks of sin and guilt, punishment and eternal wrath, and calls to repentance. He speaks of grace and pardon in Calvarys blood and calls to faith. He reveals Himself as the only way and truth and life for lost and damnworthy sinners. He calls the weary and heavy-laden, the hungry and thirsty, the contrite and those that mourn in Zion, and thus He calls His own by name.
And while He calls He works in the hearts of His sheep by His overpowering
grace and Spirit. That Spirit seeks the
wandering ones, regenerates, inclines the heart, bends the will, opens the eyes, and thus
applies the gospel call to the heart. He
convicts of sin and guilt, makes weary and contrite, leads to Calvary, sanctifies, and
prepares unto every good work. Thus the Good
Shepherd does not merely desire to bring; He brings.
The gospel is not an offer of some kind or other; it is the power of God unto
salvation.
Finally, what must and shall be the result of this bringing of Christ? Jesus says, They shall hear my voice, the voice of the Good Shepherdthe voice that speaks of incarnation and suffering and death and resurrection, of peace and reconciliation and grace and pardon in the blood that speaks of infinitely better things than the blood of Abelthe voice that speaks of righteousness in the midst of unrighteousness, blessing in the midst of curse, life in the midst of death, glory in the midst of shamethe voice that comes not only to our natural ears and minds though the preaching of the gospel, but to our hearts through the inner, mystical operation of the Spirit within.
This hearing, therefore, is a spiritual matter. Obviously, Jesus is not speaking of physical hearing and mere natural perception. In that sense, all who hear the gospel hear the voice of Jesus, also those for whom this voice is a savor of death unto death. The sheep hear His voice spiritually. It is the hearing of spiritual understanding, of personal appropriation, of obedience and faith. When Jesus calls, the sheep prick up their ears, as it were, and they come, they follow, they forsake sin and every evil way, they repent, they turn, they seek their salvation in His cross alone, they walk according to the Spirit, whereby we know that we too are sheep.
And note the certainty of it all. They shall hear. Irresistible grace! If salvation, even in the remotest sense, were dependent on man, this could not be said. But now, salvation is of the Lord. And, says Jesus, there shall be one flock and one shepherd. There shall be! Perseverance of the saints! One flock and one Shepherd. No unscriptural separation of Jew and Gentile. The sheep of the Jewish fold and those not of that fold would all become one flock, with and under the eternal Shepherd Jesus Christ.
Thus it must be to the glory of Gods grace. For there is one God, whose one glorious image, through the one Mediator, must be revealed in the one people. However, even as that one image consists of a multitude of perfections, even so that one flock must consist of a multitude of sheep, each of which must reflect that one unspeakable glory of God, to the revelation of the whole and the praise of the Father, through our Lord Jesus Christ, the one, the only Shepherd of His chosen race.
The one who gives assurance to the believing child of God, we saw last time, is the Spirit of Christ.
There is nothing surprising about this, since He is the one who gives certainty about everything. The Spirit gives the church certainty that the Bible is the inspired Word of God. We believe without any doubt all things contained in them [the sixty-six books of the Bible], not so much because the church receives and approves them as such, but more especially because the Holy Ghost witnesses in our hearts that they are from God (Belgic Confession, Art. 5).
The Spirit gives the elect believer certainty that the gospel is of God, and true, as also the certainty that Jesus Christ is Savior from sin and death. For our gospel came not unto you in word only, but also in power, and in the Holy Ghost, and in much assurance (I Thess. 1:5).
Within the divine being of the Holy Trinity, it is the Spirit who is Gods own certainty of His own infinite truth. The Spirit searcheth all things, yea, the deep things of God (I Cor. 2:10). Verse 11 adds, in explanation, that, just as it is the spirit of a man that knows the things of a man, so only the Spirit of God knows the things of God.
This Spirit of certainty, to whom doubt concerning the things of God in Christ is foreign and obnoxious, works assurance of salvation in those described in I Corinthians 2:15 as spiritual men and women. Spiritual men and women are not a few super-saints among the believers. They are not, as the Puritans taught, the few special friends of God favored with assurance, whereas all the other friends are left to languish in doubt, uncertain therefore whether they are Gods friends at all. Spiritual men and women are most certainly not those who claim, mistakenly, if not arrogantly, to have had a mystical experience, which now sets them apart from, and above, the groaning, doubting masses in the congregations.
Spiritual men and women are thoseall thosewho are born again by the Spirit, who are taught the truths of the gospel by the Spirit, and who have the mind of Christ (I Cor. 2:13, 16).
Experience
Assuring us spiritual men and women of our salvation is simply part of the Spirits saving of us at every step of the order of salvation. So far is it from being true that assurance comes only at the distant end of ones salvation, if it comes at all, that, in fact, assurance comes at the very beginning of the divine process, or order, of salvation, and at every step thereafter.
The Spirit regenerates, and with this new birth into heavenly life comes awareness that we are alive unto God. Born physically, we soon know that we are alive. We do not mope through earthly life for thirty or fifty or seventy years with an anxious look on our face, lamenting, I doubt that I am alive. So it is with the new, spiritual birth. The Spirit unites us with Christ, and the risen Christ is a commanding, compelling, charismatic presence. The birth from above makes us alive with His life, and His life is vibrant and unmistakable, particularly in love and awe of the God and Father of Jesus Christ and in hatred of sin.
The Spirit calls us to Christ Jesus by the gospel, and we come. We come to Jesus Christ. We come to Him as Savior and Lord. We come to Him as Savior and Lord of every one who comes to Him. We come to Him as our own Lord and Savior. This is assurance of salvation. Assurance of salvation belongs to His very Saviorhood and Lordship.
The Spirit gives faith, and faith is assurance, as was demonstrated in an earlier editorial.
The Spirit sanctifies, and we consecrate ourselves to God in Jesus Christ with heart, mind, soul, and strength in thankfulness for His redemption of us in Christ. The consecration that is holiness is the conviction that God is our God and we are His people. And this consecration is motivated by thankfulness for the redemption of the crossour thankfulness for Christs redemption of us by His cross. This is certainty of salvation. Certainty of salvation is essential to sanctification.
When in the day of Christ the Spirit raises our body from the grave in the glorious likeness of Christ, we will know that we are glorified. Certainty of glorification will be of the essence of glorification. No one will doubt his resurrection. Nor do I suppose that we will arrive at certainty of our resurrection by painstakingly examining each member of our glorified body, to determine that it is, in fact, a glorified finger, a glorified foot, and a glorified torso. Rather, we will spontaneously know our own resurrection with certainty by gazing with love and adoration into the face of the glorified Jesus Christ.
Every aspect of the saving work of the Spirit of Christ includes the assurance of salvation.
God does not only desire to save all His children. He also wants all His children to know and enjoy their salvation, for the consciousness of salvation is an important part of salvation.
Salvation is not only the deliverance of the sinner. It is also the sinners experience of his deliverance.
It is ironic that those who talk much about experience (leaving the distinct impression that no other Reformed church does justice to experience) are content that many believers and children of believers, members of the congregations, be shut out from all experience of salvation. Indeed, by their Puritan doctrine that faith is not assurance and that most believers must work and wait for many years to obtain assurance, as well as by the pernicious teaching of many that there is a preparatory grace in unregenerated people, they themselves rob their members of the experience of salvation. Lack of assurance is lack of experience.
We, on the other hand, who are viewed as being doctrinal (as though this were a weakness in a church, and not a churchs supreme strength), and suspected of minimizing experience, insist on the experience of salvation by all who believe and by their covenant children. The Spirit blesses our doctrinal preaching and teaching, to give this experience to all those in the covenant, adult believers and their children. Assurance is experience.
That the work of the Spirit is assuring Jesus disciples of their salvation is expressed by the name Jesus gives Him in John 16: the Comforter. If I go not away, the Comforter will not come unto you (v. 7). Whatever else the Comforter may do, He actually puts to rest the sinners fears and doubts and assures him in the midst of all his tears and struggles, God loves you; Christ died for you; you are justified by your faith in Christ; your destiny is eternal life and glory.
Some Comforter the Spirit is if He leaves us, or most of us, doubting our salvation, much, if not all, of our life.
Sealing
Then there are the texts that make the Holy Spirit the seal to us of our salvation (II Cor. 1:19-22; Eph. 1:13; Eph. 4:30). Ephesians 1:13 reads, in the Authorized Version: In whom [Christ] ye also trusted, after that ye heard the word of truth, the gospel of your salvation: in whom also after that ye believed, ye were sealed with that holy Spirit of promise.
Sealing is the assurance of one who believes in Christ that he is saved and that he shall be saved to all eternity. Calvin explained, in his commentary on the text:
The true conviction which believers have of the Word of God, of their own salvation, and of religion in general, does not spring from the judgment of the flesh, or from human and philosophical arguments, but from the sealing of the Spirit, who imparts to their consciences such certainty as to remove all doubt.
The Spirit Himself in the believer is this seal, as is indicated by verse 14, which calls Him the earnest [or deposit, or down payment] of our inheritance. The Spirit seals us in Christ: In whom [that is, in Christ] ye were sealed. There is absolutely no assurance apart from Christ. Nor does the Spirit give any assurance apart from Christ and trust in Christ as He is presented in the word of truth. All Christ-less mystical experiences, in which the Spirit and the mystic, or experientialist, have their delightful tête-à-tête, are mere fantasy, and of the devil. In Christ you trusted; in Christ you believed; in Christ, you were sealed. And verse 14 adds that the Spirit is the earnest to us until the completion in us of the redemption of the cross of Christ.
Of great importance is the teaching of Ephesians 1:13 that the sealing with the Spirit is immediately connected with ones trusting in Christ upon hearing the Word of truth. Introduction by the Authorized Version of the word after could be misleading, as though the believers sealing follows his believing in time, perhaps even a long time. Literally, the Greek text reads, . . . in whom also having believed, you were sealed with the holy Spirit of promise. There is no after in the text. When one hears the gospel of Jesus Christ and believes in Jesus Christ, he is sealedimmediately, as part and parcel of the work of the Spirit in him giving faith. Immediately, as an essential aspect of faith in Christ, the believer is assured of his salvation, now and in the day of the redemption of the purchased possession.
This is the nature of the saving work of the Spirit.
Indeed, this is the nature of the indwelling Spirit Himself. He Himself is the sealthe certainty, the assuranceof the believer.
This is the nature of the indwelling Spirit in every one who trusts in Christ, having heard the Word of truth.
Those Puritans who separated assurance from faith by many years, often by an entire lifetime, grounded their dreadful error in a mistaken interpretation of Ephesians 1:13. They explained the sealing with the Spirit as separated from, and following in timeoften many yearsones believing the Word of truth. In some of the Puritans, this error was aggravated by their teaching that the sealing, when it finally happens, is such a direct and immediate testimony of the Spirit as amounts to the mysterious experience of overpowering light (see J. I. Packer, The Witness of the Spirit: The Puritan Teaching, in Puritan Papers, vol. 1, P&R, 2000, pp. 17-29).
This Puritan doctrine of sealing (which, of course, puts assurance forever out of the reach of all but a few elite Christians) opened the way to Wesleys heresy of the second blessing and then to the charismatic movement with its doctrine of the baptism with the Spirit.
The English preacher D. Martyn Lloyd-Jones strongly advocated the separation of sealing with the Spirit from faith in Christ, with appeal to Ephesians 1:13. In this way, he became the instrument by whom the Puritan doctrine of assurance led on to the acceptance of the charismatic movement, not only in his own congregation, but also widely in so-called evangelicalism in England.
Gift
The comfort, the sealing, the witness of the Spirit of Christ, that is, assurance of salvation, is a gift. Like every other aspect of salvation and like salvation as a whole, assurance is pure, free grace.
The Spirit works assurance in all of Gods children, not because they deserve it, not because they have made themselves worthy of it by many years of maturing in their faith, and not because they themselves work for it and finally obtain it by their noble efforts. God forbid! But the Spirit gives Gods people assurance because God graciously is pleased, not only to adopt children, but also to have these children know Him as their Father, and themselves, His children for Christs sake.
The Spirit gives assurance by giving faith. Faith is a gift. One of the two elements of true faith, according to Q. 21 of the Heidelberg Catechism, is assurance. Giving faith, the Spirit gives assurance.
To be condemned is the Puritan doctrine that assurance is something Christians must work for, must obtain themselves by their hard work, and must make themselves worthy of over many years. This doctrine concerning the assurance of salvation is not a whit different from the teaching of Rome and of Arminianism: salvation by mans own efforts, his own heroic running and willing. The result is the same: widespread, God-dishonoring, destructive doubt.
J. I. Packer describes this Puritan error (and really defends it) in his article in the book, Puritan Papers, referred to above. Most Christians do not have assurance at once when they believe. Assurance is reserved for only a few Christians: Gods best and dearest friends. Most of those who do finally obtain assurance get it many years after their conversion.
But what now accounts for Gods favoritism? What makes these few Christians His dearest friends? Why do these few finally get assurance?
Not Gods mercy!
But their own efforts!
Assurance, writes Packer, describing the Puritan doctrine, is not normally enjoyed except by those who have first laboured for it and sought it, and served God faithfully and patiently without it (p. 20).
This doctrine is a form of the heresy of salvation by works. The salvation in view is assurance. The works are laboring, seeking, and serving faithfully and patiently. The doctrine breeds, and breathes, pride. A few worthy souls get assurance by their own hard work. The doctrine produces doubt. Who can ever be sure that he has worked long and hard enough?
To set the believer to the work of energetic service of God, hard spiritual struggle, and intense Christian warfare for many years, while depriving him of the assurance of salvation, is like telling a man to run a race, after you have cut his legs off. There can be no spiritual struggle, Christian warfare, or service of God without assurance of salvation.
I speak personally, but in the name of the children of the covenant.
I have believed since my earliest years. If I had to fight my spiritual battles uncertain of Gods love and my salvation, I would have perished in my warfare a hundred, no, a thousand times. If I had to serve God doubting whether He was my Father, I would have quit before I began.
I fought and endured, I patiently served, I struggled in my calling in the covenant of grace, sometimes intensely, because I was certain of the love of God for me personally in Jesus Christ my Lord.
Doubters cannot faithfully and patiently serve God. Doubters cannot struggle and fight in and on behalf of the covenant and kingdom of Christ. Doubters cannot live a vigorous, healthy, joyful Christian life of holiness.
Whatever got into the heads of the Puritans, learned divines and in many respects wise teachers of the gospel, when it came to the vital matter of assurance? Why do Reformed ministers doggedly follow them today?
If I have a sick child, mentally and emotionally sick, who is always dragging himself about the house asking, Am I your child? Did you beget or adopt me? Do you really love me? it is nonsense to demand of him a vigorous life. He will contribute precious little to the healthy life of the family. He will be no great joy to his parents. The poor fellow must be healed.
Assurance is not the achievement of sick, doubting Christians.
Assurance is a gift. It is the gift of the grace of God in Jesus Christ by the Spirit.
Reformed thinking about assurance does not speak of a quest for assurance. That is Puritan thinking and talk, implying the obtaining of assurance by ones own efforts. The Reformed faith confesses the gift of (full) assurance. Assurance is an essential element of faith (Heid. Cat., Q. 21). Faith is the gift of God (Canons, III, IV/14). Shall we indeed speak of a necessary quest for faith?
Reformed believer, do not work for assurance. Rather, receive it, and enjoy it, by and with faith.
Assurance of salvation, like the salvation of which it is a precious part, is not of works, lest anyone should boast (for example, of being one of Gods best and dearest friends).
Assurance is of grace, so that he that glories should glory in the Lord.
P.S.
In the end, time ran out after all. There is more to be said about assurance. I have more to say about assurance. The series on assurance is unfinished. Perhaps, another day, in other space.
For the past sixteen years, it has been my responsibility, but also my privilege, to serve the members of the Protestant Reformed Churches as editor of the Standard Bearer. In some small way, I may hope, a much wider audience has benefited. Nearly half the present subscriptions to the magazine go outside the Protestant Reformed Churches. Responses, public and private, have indicated appreciation, as well as vigorous opposition, from without.
Although the Standard Bearer exists primarily for the building up of the members of the Protestant Reformed Churches in the truth, it is also a voice, sometimes friendly, at other times critical, but always deeply interested, to the entire Reformed community worldwide. I need not mention the issues, controversies, and developments affecting the broad Reformed community that were addressed in the editorials. Even when I was speaking to the Protestant Reformed Churches, I seldom forgot the distant relations listening in. To paraphrase the church father, I am Reformed. I esteem nothing Reformed foreign to me.
I acknowledge, not the assistance, but the cooperation of the managing editor. We simply worked together to publish a magazine that would be the very best in appearance and content we could make it.
At long last, I may, and must, publicly express my gratitude for the help of my wife in this work now completed. During the first five hectic years, without complaint she virtually gave up having a husband. She has always read the editorials and other articles of mine before they were published, with a critical eye. Now and again, she wisely moderated, not the zeal of the editor, but certain sharper expressions of his zeal (which moderation will come as a surprise to some).
The Standard Bearer has not deviated from the course laid out by my illustrious predecessors. It maintains, develops, applies, defends, and boldly promotes creedal Reformed Christianity as confessed by the Protestant Reformed Churches. God be praised!
We may confidently expect the same from the capable men who now take on the editorship. They will, of course, add their own insights in their own styles. God bless and prosper their work!
Eighty years of faithful witness to the truth of the sovereignty and glory of the God and Father of Jesus Christ, and our God and Father for Christs sake!
The Standard Bearer is now the oldest continuously published, subscription-based Reformed magazine in North Americaa tribute, not from associations of periodicals, but from the providence of God.
May its witness long continue!
May its witness increasingly be heard!
Finally, then,
A Defense of the
Presbyterian Doctrine of Infant BaptismFinally
The Presbyterian Doctrine of Children in the Covenant: An Historical Study of the Significance of Infant Baptism in the Presbyterian Church, by Lewis Bevens Schenck. Phillipsburg, New Jersey: P&R, 2003. Pp. xvii + 188. $15.99 (paper).
Infant Salvation in the Covenant
The message of this reprint of a work first published in 1940 is precious. It is traditional, confessional Presbyterian (Reformed) doctrine that infant baptism means the infant salvation of the elect children of godly parents. Parents and the church must view and rear the baptized children as elect and regenerated. The doctrine of the historic Reformed church [is] that since the promise is not only to parents but to their seed, children are by the command of God to be regarded and treated as of the number of the elect (p. 127). Right, covenantal upbringing consists of the gradual nurture of the children in the salvation they possess from infancy.
Christian nurture was, then, the appointed, the natural, the normal, and ordinary means by which the children of believers were made truly the children of God. Consequently it was the method which these leaders believed should be principally relied upon and employed for the salvation of their children. They recognized a marvelous adaptation of this means to the end which it was intended to accomplish, and they were convinced that success was assured to them in its use by the covenant promise of God (p. 145).
Schenck demonstrates that this doctrine of infant baptism was that of John Calvin, Charles Hodge, Abraham Kuyper, and others, as well as that of all the Reformed confessions. Reformed orthodoxy was in fundamental agreement with Calvin.
Baptism has no significance for Calvin if it does not mean admission to the visible church on the ground of the covenant promise, which includes the presumptive regeneration of the children in the covenant. Calvin looks upon the child in the covenant as Gods child, forgiven of sin and regenerated, with the new life as a latent seed, already at work in its heart. The child then opens its eyes redeemed on a world in which by careful nurture it is expected to grow and develop in the Christian ideal of life and character. The important point is that this child is presumptively a Christian (p. 13).
Although presumptive and presumptively do not do justice to Calvin, for Calvin did not presume, but believed that infant baptism means infant regeneration, and although the analysis does not make as plain as it could that Calvin referred to the elect children of godly parents, this account of Calvins doctrine is right. Calvin saw infant baptism as signifying infant salvation.
That this was Calvins teaching, Schenck proves by this quotation from Calvin:
The offspring of believers are born holy, because their children, while yet in the womb, before they breathe the vital air, have been adopted into the covenant of eternal life. Nor are they brought into the church by baptism on any other ground than because they belonged to the body of the Church before they were born. He who admits aliens to baptism profanes it . For how can it be lawful to confer the badge of Christ on aliens from Christ. Baptism must, therefore, be preceded by the gift of adoption, which is not the cause of half salvation merely, but gives salvation entire: and this salvation is afterwards ratified by Baptism (p. 13).
Presumptive Unregeneration
Schenck takes dead aim at the radically un-Reformed doctrine of infant baptism that was prominent in Presbyterian churches already in 1940 and that prevails today. This is the teaching that infant baptism means nothing more than that the children of believers are formally and externally set apart as likely, or possible, candidates for salvation in later years. The children are viewed, and taught to view themselves, as unregenerated. As regards their spiritual condition, baptized children of believers are no different from the ungodly world.
A Presbyterian theologian who taught this un-Presbyterian doctrine of infant baptism put it this way:
While they [baptized children of believers] are in the church by external union, in the spirit and temper of their minds they belong to the world.Of the world and in the Churchthis expresses precisely their status, and determines the mode in which the church should deal with them (p. 93).
Accordingly, parents and church do not rear the children in godliness. Rather, they try to convert them, just as missionaries try to convert the heathen outside the church. And the conversion looked for by parents, church, and children alike is a dramatic experience.
This is the miserable doctrine of infant baptism taught and practiced today by many churches that profess the covenant with the children of believers and baptize infants. The doctrine is not Presbyterian (Reformed). It is Baptist through and through. This is why these nominally Presbyterian (Reformed) ministers can readily cooperate with those who are Baptist in name as well as in fact. An outstanding instance is the Banner of Truth organization, headquartered in Edinburgh, Scotland. Presbyterian in reputation and much of its leadership, the organization and its ministries allow themselves to be heavily influenced by Baptists and the Baptist denial of the covenant. The editor of the magazine and now also the Editor of the Trust are Baptists, to say nothing of many of the writers and lecturers.
The timeliness of Schencks warning against this apostasy from the Presbyterian doctrine of infant baptism and therefore from the covenant is illustrated by the publication last year of a fat volume in which many Presbyterian and Reformed theologians from many different denominations advocated and defended the doctrine of infant baptism Schenck condemns. The book is erroneously and misleadingly entitled The Case for Covenantal Infant Baptism. Ironically, the publisher is the same as the publisher of The Presbyterian Doctrine of Children in the Covenant (see my review article, A Presbyterian Case for the Baptist Rejection of Infant Baptism, in the February 15, 2004 issue of the Standard Bearer).
Anti-Covenant Revivals
The cause of the falling away of Presbyterians from the Presbyterian doctrine of infant baptism was the Great Awakening under Jonathan Edwards, the Tennents, Whitefield, and others in the early eighteenth century. The theory of the salvation of the church and of individuals by revivals insists that salvation be a matter of dramatic conversion experiences. Applied to the children of believers, as it was by all the revivalists (Edwards famously regarded his own and others baptized children as little vipers), the notion of revival destroyed the truth of infant baptism. In its place came the hope that God would one day save the little baptized heathen by a conversion experience urgently exhorted upon, and often extorted from, the children by parents and wandering evangelists.
The Great Awakening made an emotional experience, involving terror, misery, and depression, the only approach to God. A conscious conversion from enmity to friendship with God was looked upon as the only way of entrance into the kingdom. Sometimes it came suddenly, sometimes it was a prolonged and painful process. But it was believed to be a clearly discernible emotional upheaval, necessarily distinct to the consciousness of its subject and apparent to those around. Preceding the experience of Gods love and peace, it was believed necessary to have an awful sense of ones lost and terrifying position. Since these were not the experiences of infancy and early childhood, it was taken for granted children must, or in all ordinary cases would, grow up unconverted. Infants, it was thought, needed the new birth, as well as adults. They could not be saved without it. But the only channel of the new birth which was recognized was a conscious experience of conviction and conversion. Anything else, according to Gilbert Tennent, was a fiction of the brain, a delusion of the Devil. In fact, he ridiculed the idea that one could be a Christian without knowing the time when he was otherwise (p. 71).
Heathenizing the Church
This un- (and anti-) Presbyterian doctrine of infant baptism is grievous error. It is sin against infant baptism and covenantal salvation. In addition, it implies a doctrine of the church that is both defaming of and dangerous to the body of Christ. The church is described as a gathering of regenerated (adult believers) and unregenerated (children). As an assembly whose membership includes a large number of unregenerated personsall the childrenthe church becomes a mission field. Preaching to the church, which is by definition the assembly of those called out of the ungodly world, takes the incongruous and disobedient form of mission-preaching to heathens, albeit baptized heathens. Christ tells pastors to feed His sheep and lambs. The revivalist and Baptistic doctrine of infant baptism in Presbyterian and Reformed churches has pastors feeding the sheep and converting their little vipers.
Later, when the unregenerated children grow up and marry, these unbelievers are permitted to baptize their own unregenerated children. Although Schenck does not make the observation, what this amounts to is the horrific doctrine that God establishes His covenant with unbelievers and their unsaved children.
Further, since the children are viewed as unregenerated, no church discipline can be exercised upon them.
What was the use of judicial discipline for children in the covenant, anyway, it was argued? No claim was made that they were in Christ, and their offenses were consequently no reproach to His name. Besides, it was thought to be absurd to use spiritual remedies on one who had no adaptation to receive them, who had never heard the voice of God in his soul (p. 95).
Schenck is right, explaining Calvins doctrine: To baptize infants while denying the infant salvation of elect children is a denial of the truth of Gods covenant promise (p. 21).
It is worth noting that Schenck shows that historic Presbyterianism has always distinguished the essence and the administration of the covenant (p. 122). The administration of the covenant includes many who are not saved. The essence of the covenant is enjoyed only by the elect. All the children of believing parents are in the sphere of the covenant. Only the elect children are in the covenant.
The Presbyterian Doctrine of Children in the Covenant is no longer the doctrine of covenant children of most Presbyterians. May it become so once again.
Rev.
Laning is pastor of Hope Protestant Reformed Church in Walker, Michigan.
Reformed believers officially confess to believe the apostolicity of the church. The Nicene Creed is one of our official creeds, and in this creed we confess to believe one holy catholic and apostolic church. Thus it is very important that we understand the meaning of the churchs apostolicity, so that we may confess this truth with understanding from the heart.
When considering the apostolicity of the church we once again make a distinction between the church as the universal body of the elect and the church as an institute upon this earth. First of all, it is the church as the universal body of the elect that is apostolic. The passages cited below to prove the apostolicity of the church refer to the church as the universal body of Christ. But this truth also applies to the church as institute, and thus it is proper to refer to a faithful church upon this earth as an apostolic church.
The Apostolic Church:
That the church is apostolic means that it is built upon the truth set forth by the apostles in the New Testament. Apostolicity has to do with the very foundation of the church. A true church is built upon the Truth, since Christ is the Truth, and this Truth has been set forth infallibly for us by the divinely inspired apostles in the New Testament.
The Scriptures make specific reference to this in a number of places. First, there is
Ephesians 2:20,
which says that
the church is built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Jesus Christ
himself being the chief corner stone. Here
the truth revealed through the apostles and prophets is referred to as the
foundation of the church. The prophets
referred to in this passage were the inspired prophets of Pauls day, as is evident
from the other references to the prophets in the book of Ephesians (cf.
Eph. 3:5;
4:11).
In Revelation 21:14, we read the following symbolic description of the heavenly city, the new Jerusalem: And the wall of the city had twelve foundations, and in them the names of the twelve apostles of the Lamb. Clearly the reference here is to the apostles not as mere men, but as ambassadors of Christ who spoke the words of Christ. To be built upon the apostles is to be built upon the truth spoken and written by the apostles.
That this is the idea is found more explicitly elsewhere in Scripture. In Acts 2:42, we read that the believers in the new dispensation continued stedfastly in the apostles doctrine and fellowship. Still today the believers are those who remain in the apostles doctrine. A church that is truly apostolic is one that continues to proclaim the same truth that the apostles proclaimed and wrote down infallibly in the New Testament Scriptures.
Apostolicity & the Relation
But if the church is built upon the truth set forth by the apostles in the New Testament, what does that mean for the Old Testament? Obviously it does not mean that the New Testament writings are the only ones to which we hold. Rather, it means that when one is holding to the truth set forth by the apostles in the New Testament, he is, in fact, also holding to the truth set forth in the Old Testament, since it is the same truth taught in both the Old and New Testaments. In addition to this, however, it does mean that there is a certain priority to the New Testament. It is in the New Testament that we have a divinely inspired explanation of what is taught in the law and the prophets of the Old Testament. For example, the truth of the Trinity is taught in the Old Testament, but in our creeds we confess that this truth which appears to us somewhat obscure in the Old Testament is very plain in the New (Belgic Confession, Article 9).
To reject the New Testament explanation of the Old Testament is really to deny the apostolicity of the church. For example, there are many who take the Old Testament promises concerning all nations coming to Christ, and say that these promises are teaching that one day soon every nation on this earth will be governed by Christian rulers. Such people try to prove their position by quoting frequently from the Old Testament, while ignoring the apostolic explanation of these promises that is found in the New Testament. The apostles said that the promises concerning all nations coming to Christ are fulfilled when a remnant from the different nations is converted and believes in Jesus (Acts 15:17). The rejection of this is a rejection of the truth of Scripture and very really a rejection of the apostolicity of the church.
A Succession of the Truth,
The Romish church says that she alone is the apostolic church because, so she claims, there is a continuous line of succession from the present pope back to the apostle Peter, and from the bishops in the Romish church back to the other apostles. Peter, they say, was the first pope and the rock upon which their church is built. To prove this, they have invented a long line of popes, starting with Peter and ending with their present leader, Pope John Paul II.
Contrary to this, we say that maintaining the truth taught by the apostles is what is important. Let us say, just for the purpose of argument, that Peter was the first pastor of the church in Rome. This would by no means prove that the Romish church today is an apostolic church. All around the world there are churches that once had faithful pastors proclaiming the truth of the gospel, which now have completely apostatized. We know from the epistle to the Romans found in Scripture that there once was a sound church in Rome, a church that was founded by the teaching of the apostles. But this church later apostatized, so that it no longer was an apostolic church. At the time of the Protestant Reformation, the Reformers knew that the Romish church had a long history, going back to the days of the apostles, but the Romish church had long ago departed from the teaching of the apostles. The Reformers reformed the church by breaking away from this apostate institute and forming congregations that were based squarely and solely on the truth set forth by the apostles in the Scriptures.
The Romish church, of course, rejects this, and appeals to her catholicity to prove her apostolicity. The church that is truly holding to the truth taught by the apostles will be a church visibly spread throughout the whole world, she says, and churches holding to false doctrines will be confined to only a few regions. But this is based, in part, on Romes false view of what is meant by the catholicity of the church, a view that was refuted in the previous article. There is one central mark that indicates whether or not an instituted church is a true manifestation of the one catholic and apostolic church, and that is the mark of the pure preaching of the apostles gospel. A true church is a church that preaches the apostolic doctrine, no matter how small she may be, and no matter how few like-minded churches she can find with whom she can enjoy fellowship.
Remaining steadfast in the apostles doctrine is our calling. It is the church that does this, and only the church that does this, that also groweth unto an holy temple in the Lord (Eph. 2:21). It is the apostolic church that is holy, living apart from this world and in close covenant communion with her God and Husband.
Rev.
Koole is pastor of Grandville Protestant Reformed Church in Grandville, Michigan.
In the wake of Romes sex-abuse scandal the U.S. conference of Catholic bishops undertook an investigation into the allegations against its priests and the irresponsible response of its Bishops. The results have recently been published. According to the study, the bishops concluded that 4,392 priests allegedly have abused more than 10,000 victims over a 50-year time span. [You may be sure this is the most favorable estimation (and spin) possible.]
What is noteworthy is that the study was honest enough to acknowledge that the molesting priests were by and large homosexual. This is one of the dirty little secrets of the homosexual lifestyle. From the homosexual population come the predators of young teenage boys. And it has nothing to do with consent. The gay-liberation movement (with its supporting politicians) has not welcomed such press. The liberal news media has acted equally ignorant that such might be the case. Truth is not what such folks are looking for.
Now, however, in response to Romes bishops study, a book has been written by an openly homosexual author, David France. It is entitled Our Fathers: The Secret Life of the Catholic Church in an Age of Scandal. In this book, in a surprising admission, France acknowledges that the offending priests were homosexual after all. He had little choice in the matter. He interviewed a number of the priests involved, and they all informed him that they were gay. Um-m-m-m. Imagine that! Now what?
What should not surprise us is where Mr. France has decided to put the blame. It is not on the offenders themselves, of course. In an article entitled Homophobia Blamed for Priests Abuse (Agape Press), reporters Ed Vitagliono and Sherrie Black inform us just where Mr. France thinks the blame should be. In an interview by a pro-gay magazine, France stated
[W]e now know from talking to these priests [who molested teenagers]: theyre gay, France told The Advocate, a magazine targeted to the homosexual community, adding, And if they were gay men, we should ask ourselves why that was happening. What caused it?
What is Frances explanation in Our Fathers? What I argue is that these guys represent homosexuality in pure and total repression, he said. This is what successful repression looks like: men so alienated from their own sense of self that their sexual expression came out in explosive ways.
So, it is all due to homophobia. The real offenders are not the priests who did the molesting. Rather, they themselves, like those upon whom they preyed, are to be numbered amongst the victims. The real perps are those in society and church guilty of condemning homosexuality and calling such behavior a forbidden thing. This means, of course, that those really to blame for this whole sordid mess are those who had nothing to do with the scandalous behavior and those with whom adolescent boys would be perfectly safe. Why of course! Who else?
Unbelievable! The brazenness and illogicalness of the reasoning leaves one gasping. But we live in an age when such reasoning is more and more considered compelling and sound. An intellectual madness rules.
The question that begs to be asked of France and his cronies is, So what are you implying? If I understand you right, it is this the desire for adolescent boys is due to the repression of homosexual desires. Therefore we should let such men pursue their desires (just be themselves), and, if society and church would simply give these men free rein to pursue their cravings, then suddenly young boys would be safe. In other words, the only way to make sure your adolescent boys are safe from such men, is to let such men loose amongst your adolescent boys. Amazing. Who has heard of anything quite so insane. Yet, today this makes perfect sense.
Fortunately, not everyone as yet has bought into such reasoning. The article also points out
That explanation is rejected by pro-family groups. So Frances solution would be for the Catholic Church to embrace homosexuality and allow practicing homosexuals to serve as priests? And then the abuse would stop? asked Tim Wildmon, president of the American Family Association. Thats ridiculous fantasy denied by history and the undercurrents within gay culture. The real solution is to make sure that homosexuals arent in the priesthood.
How true. The trouble is, as the article goes on to say, Rome continues to reassign priests charged with such behavior to other parishes incognito, and so the cycle continues. Ever true to herself, Rome really admits to very little and essentially changes nothing about itself in this area either.
In the end, what the laws and the judges that are granting the homosexual lifestyle legal protection and recognition are aiming at is no secret. Its the freedom of the pulpit. An article entitled Hate-Crime Law Worries Pastors: Some consider liability insurance to cover pulpit remarks (Worldnet Daily) makes this very plain.
Pennsylvania (not exactly known as a hotbed for the liberal movement) now has laws against hate-crimes on its books. It just recently approved of amendments to these laws that make the interpretation of what constitutes a hate-crime very broad indeed. As of June, harassment by communication now constitutes a hate-crime. No wonder churches and pastors in the Quaker state are beginning to shake a bit.
A religious liberty group is trying to reassure Pennsylvania pastors who fear they could face prosecution under a new law if they preach against homosexuality.
The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty sent a letter to 9,000 houses of worship across the state June 18 after a hate-crimes law was amended to add sexual orientation and gender identity as motives that trigger heavier penalties for the crimes of harassment.
It is a measure of our times that religious leaders have lately considered taking out liability insurance to cover remarks made from the pulpit, said Becket Fund President Kevin J. Hasson.
Of particular concern to pastors is the amendments expansion of the definition of harassment to include harassment by communication which means one could be convicted on the basis of spoken words alone.
Although legislators expressly disavowed the motive at the time, one might be forgiven the impression that one purpose of this legislation was to generate a fear of prosecution among those who would preach and teach in favor of the traditional prohibition on homosexual behavior a teaching so common to so many faiths, Hasson noted.
However, the Becket Funds letter explained to clergy that the new law should not deter them from preaching against homosexual conduct.
The group says that although the language of the law appears to cover preaching from the pulpit, it is unlikely to be applied that way.
The Becket Fund also offered to help ministers threatened with such prosecution. We will defend, free of charge, anything said from the pulpit, conservative or liberal, wisdom or nonsense, so long as it is a religious message given in good faith, Hasson declared.
Will such a law be used against the pulpit, churches, and preachers who speak out against homosexuality? You had better believe it will. We do not doubt that Mr. Hasson says what he says in good faith. He simply cannot bring himself to believe anybody would stoop so low as to use this law to charge preachers (who condemned the homosexual lifestyle as displeasing to God) with being guilty of hate-crimes. Legislators assured him this was not their intention.
Brother Hasson is mistaken. He may be sure that the one main purpose of those promoting the Pennsylvania legislation is exactly ...to generate fear of prosecution among those who would preach and teach in favor of the traditional prohibition on homosexual behavior. Supporters of the gay-movement are convinced that the primary generator of hate and prejudice against homosexuality (by calling it sin and deviant behavior) is the Christian church and its pulpits. They intend to get at such. This legislation, all pious blandishments aside, simply gives them the legal club with which to do it down the road.
And Pennsylvanias legislation is an indicator of the coming wave.
The above heading is within quotation marks. I cannot take credit for it. It is another mans phrase a certain Jim Elliff, writing an article for the Baptist Press. It is timely. It hits home.
Sports has become much of Christianitys new god. Those of us living in West Michigan can verify that. Last month the Grand Rapids Press ran a three part series on Christians (of the Reformed community in particular) getting more and more involved in Sunday sports in every way as fans, as participants, as professionals earning their living [desecrating] the Lords Day. The Grand Rapids community has noticed this development. The Grand Rapids Press thought it high time for the Christian community, its Reformed section in particular, to explain (and justify) itself after so long having condemned those who played on the Lords Day.
The same Christian churches that so recently condemned sports and recreation as a transgression of the Lords Holy Day, now have members out there hitting a pitching wedge to the green and trying to leg out a double with the best (worst?) of them. Professing Christians lead the Sunday hit parade. What gives? What changed? The community wonders.
The Christian apologists did their best to explain. According to the apologists, the new freedom to violate the Lords Day has to do with Christian maturity, that is, Christians finally growing up and learning not to be so legalistic, that is, judging others by ones own personal preference as to what one may or may not do on the Lords Day. Spiritual maturity means each has the right to determine for oneself whats the best use of the Lords Day for ones spiritual growth. Some evidently find arguing with an umpire over another blown call another step in their spiritual development.
In short, it appears to me what comes to light is a new insight into the Bible, in particular a passage we evidently have misinterpreted for all too long: When I was a child, I spake as a child, I thought as a child: but when I became a man, (and spiritually mature), I embraced with even greater fervor childish things and refused to put them away even on the Lords Day. I am sure that is what I Corinthians 13:11 really must have meant to say.
Evidently the Baptist community where Jim Elliff lives is dealing with the same sports craze our Reformed community is dealing with here in West Michigan. He writes as one who knows.
I love to watch my kids play sports. In fact they need to play some.
But its not as easy as handing over 70 bucks and saying, Sign up Johnny and Susie this year. Making that decision means that you may be out four to five times each week during the season. Sports soon becomes all about calendarization [sic] and control of your life especially if you have more than one kid. Perhaps nothing outside of a change in your job has so much potential to turn the family schedule upside down.
This man understands, you say.
Now comes the part you wont like: Behold, I say unto you, you have made sports the household god. Too strong? Okay, not everyone has done this. But the deification of sports is happening to many.
How does ball become Baal? Answer: When it controls you, and you give it devoted worship. It is around your god that you order your life and you can almost never say no to it.
Like athletes foot on the hygienically challenged teenager, sports has taken over more and more of the life of believers. Almost overnight we have awakened to the sad fact that, in many communities, sports has even usurped the hours believers meet on the Lords Day.
All too often members are saying to church leaders, Well be gone next Sunday because of the soccer tournament. In turn, leaders are supposed to acquiesce humbly. After all, we cant afford to appear legalistic; everyone knows that the greatest crime a church can commit is to demand something of someone.
Youll hear, But the team needs all the players. We cant let the team down. It never occurs to them that the church body is being deprived of a necessary body part, or that God is marginalized and disobeyed. We are not to forsake the assembling of ourselves together, God states in Hebrews 10:25.
Devotion is the operative word. When the team says, We need you, we sacrifice to do it. But when it crosses the time allotted to spiritual edification and worship, the Ruler of the universe is often sent to the bench. In the process, we teach our children that devotion to sports is more important than both devotion to God and loyalty to our spiritual family. Have you considered that you may be teaching your kids to worship sports?
Timely.
The Olympics are past, and fall sports loom on the horizon, both school and professional. Has ball become Baal with us? Dont say it is not there.
And what is happening in our homes on Sundays?
Do we really think watching on our televisions Sammy Sosa take another mighty cut or Phil Mickelson go for another major or the Lions take on the Bears on Sunday afternoon is any different than watching in the stadium itself? Do we really think one Apostle would join us and commend such Christianity?
Come now.
To what extent is ball becoming Baal in our family rooms on Sunday afternoons? The angels must weep.
Praying Together for True Revival, by Jonathan Edwards. Ed. T. M. Moore. Phillipsburg, New Jersey: P&R Publishing, 2004. Pp. xvii + 204. $11.99 (paper). [Reviewed by the editor.]
In connection with the 300th anniversary of Edwards birth in 1703, a number of works by and about Jonathan Edwards are appearing. Praying Together is one of Edwards own works under a new title. The original title was, in shortened form, An Humble Attempt to Promote Explicit Agreement and Visible Union of Gods People in Extraordinary Prayer for the Revival of Religion and the Advancement of Christs Kingdom on Earth, Pursuant to Scripture Promises and Prophecies Concerning the Last Time. The book was first published in 1747.
The book is Edwards plea that all Christians unite at stated times over several years to pray for worldwide revival of true religion.
Edwards was enthusiastic for revivals. For the welfare and growth of the church in the world, he looked, in large part, to extraordinary outpourings of the Spirit. The united prayer of many over a long time would move God to send these revivals. Edwards found biblical support for revivals everywhere in Scripture, especially in the Old Testament.
Basic to his zeal for revival and his plea for united prayer on behalf of revival was Edwards pronounced postmillennialism. He expected the future glorious advancement of the church, the churchs latter-day glory. Such was his hope for the earthly future of the church that he foretold the conversion of vast multitudes, the saving of all nations in at least the majority of their citizens and in their rulers, and a long period of earthly peace and prosperity for the saints. One wonders whether there will be any unsaved at all. No Christian Reconstructionist outdoes Edwards in describing the earthly triumph of the church. That which would accomplish this glorious age of the church would be the final and great revival. And the revival will come about by Edwards huge prayer chain.
Edwards postmillennial dream may not have been whimsical, as he put it. But it was false doctrine. The prayer for worldwide revival, which was based on the postmillennial error, wasand isrebellion against God. God has made known in His Word that His will for the last time is not the churchs earthly glory, but the abounding of lawlessness in the world, the apostasy of the visible church, and the great tribulation of the remnant. Nor did the united prayers for the great revival by Edwards and the many who listened to him change Gods revealed will. There was no great revival then or later.
All the New Testaments teaching of lawlessness, apostasy, and persecution in the last days, Edwards dispensed with by thrusting it into the past. He recognized that these prophecies were a damp to prayer for the great revival and the golden age of the church. All, therefore, were said by Edwards to have been fulfilled at the Reformation, when the papacy supposedly was destroyed. Edwards was a preterist, as all postmillennialists are forced to be.
Implicit in the call to united prayer for revival by all churches and Christians was an illegitimate ecumenicity. Genuine oneness in the Spirit is not effected or displayed by union in praying, but by unity in doctrine.
Evident in postmillennial Edwards as in all other dreamers of the dream of the churchs earthly victory is a singular disinterest in seeing Christ. According to postmillennialism, Christ does not return to be seen and enjoyed by redeemed men and women until the long ages of the millennium have rolled on.
The postmillennialists burn to see the churchs latter-day glory. Amillennialists long to see Jesus Christ.
Postmillennialists are much in prayer for the golden age of the church. The prayer, day and night, of the amillennialist is, Come, Lord Jesus, come quickly.
Justification, by Francis Turretin. Tr. George Musgrave Giger. Ed. James T. Dennison, Jr. Phillipsburg, New Jersey: P&R, 2004. Pp. xxvi + 115. $9.99 (paper). [Reviewed by the editor.]
This one hundred-page excerpt from Francis Turretins work of Reformed theology is timely. Unbelievably, Reformed and Presbyterian churches are being troubled by brazen attack on the truth of justification. To a large extent, the ministers and theologians either support the heretics or fail to give clear, sharp instruction on justification that will expose the heresy and help the troubled members of the congregations.
Francis Turretin, seventeenth century Swiss theologian and professor of theology at Calvins Academy in Geneva, gave clear, thorough, polemical instruction on the fundamental truth of justification.
Those directly involved in the life-and-death struggle with the current false gospel of justification by faith and the works of faith should read this short work. All Reformed Christians will profit from it. In a few places, the going gets heavy, but for the most part the layman will have no trouble understanding the language and following the arguments. The instruction is biblical.
The importance of the sound doctrine of justification, Turretin indicated at the outset.
Justification must be handled with the greater care and accuracy as this saving doctrine is of the greatest importance in religion. It is called by Luther the article of a standing and a falling church. By other Christians, it is termed the characteristic and basis of Christianitynot without reasonthe principal rampart of the Christian religion. This being adulterated or subverted, it is impossible to retain purity of doctrine in other places. Hence Satan in every way has endeavored to corrupt this doctrine in all ages, as has been done especially in the papacy (p. 1).
R.C. Sproul has a hard-hitting introduction to the book. He affirms the fundamental importance of justification by faith alone to the gospel as indicated in Luthers assessment, the article of a standing and a falling church.
Without this doctrine the church falls; she collapses into ruin. She ceases to be a true church. Though every other article of historic Christian faith remains intactif this one (sola fide [by faith alone]) is lost, the church is lost with it (p. vii).
One of the serious questions raised today regarding the Reformations doctrine of justification is that which Norman Shepherd taught for years at Westminster Theological Seminary.
The controversy at Westminster Theological Seminary in Philadelphia over theologian Norman Shepherds teaching regarding justification remains unresolved. The number of Shepherds followers has increased over the years since he was dismissed from Westminster (p. xiii).
The next-to-the-last chapter considers the question whether there is an eternal justification.
The last chapter explains the justification that takes place at the final judgment.
The Path of True Godliness, by Willem Teellinck. Tr. Annemie Godbehere. Ed. Joel R. Beeke. Grand Rapids: Baker, 2003. Pp. 303. $19.99 (paper). [Reviewed by the editor.]
Wrtten by a prominent Reformed minister in the Netherlands, Willem Teellinck, early in the seventeenth century, The Path of True Godliness is a book about godliness. Teellinck defined godliness as a gift of God by which man is made willing and able to serve God.
In keeping with Teellincks conviction that the purpose of the Christian faith is a godly life, the book is intensely practical from the first page to the last. The concerned pastor urged upon the individual Christian the attitudes of heart and behavior of life that ought to adorn the doctrines of the gospel. What he exhorted, he drew from Scripture.
The godly realize that the greatest disgrace is to boast of possessing and agreeing with the purest doctrine yet failing to show the power of godliness and to avoid evil in their lives. This makes them walk carefully and live a modest life so that their lives are more righteous than those of the pagan moralist philosophers of yesterday and the legalistic sectarians of today. We read in 1 Corinthians 9:25-27, 2 Corinthians 11:12, and Philippians 4:8 that such was the practice of the godly Paul (pp. 104, 105).
It is evident that Teellinck saw, or thought he saw, worldliness in the members of the Dutch Reformed churches. Against it, he struck out sharply and pointedly. One weakness was the drinking, gluttony, and dubious merriment at weddings. Teellinck returned to this evil again and again. His warning against such corruption of the Christian fellowship at weddings is timely. Professing Reformed Christians permit excessive drinking, ribald jokes, ungodly noise passing for music, and even dancing at the wedding receptions for which they are responsible.
Imagine the scene of people who profess to be Christians having a drinking party in a dirty tavern. Or think of the frivolous and inappropriate behavior of such people at a carnival or festival or sinful wedding feast. Imagine that some Muslims, pagans, or Turks who were present heard these so-called Christians ranting, raving, boasting, and drinking. If they asked what kind of people they were and learned that they were Christians, would this not cause them to despise the God of all Christians, the one who is the true God? When they see so-called Christians lying, deceiving, and cheating, will this not give them the wrong impression of the Christian God? A Christians sinful lifestyle is a very strong way of blaspheming the name of the mighty and true God (p. 287).
Here and there, Teellinck is guilty of disturbing, erroneous teaching of universal, resistible grace. We must let the loving-kindness of God win us over to true repentance and the practice of godliness, or we will perish (p. 241). Jesus knock[s] on our hearts with kind invitations (Rev. 3:20), desiring to save us, and we should let him in (p. 245). The Holy Spirit promises to give you a new heart and a new spirit when you sincerely decide to practice godliness (p. 245; emphasis added). Seeing that the Lord God offers to take away our hearts of stone and give us new hearts and spirits in order to serve him well, how can we still refuse him? (p. 247).
This serious departure from the gospel of sovereign, particular grace is both the more significant and the more inexcusable in view of the fact that the book was first published in 1621two years after the Synod of Dordt condemned such teaching as Arminian heresy. There was reason why, as the editor notes, some Reformed leaders put him [Teellinck] in league with the Arminians (p. 22).
The Path of True Godliness is one of several smaller works on Reformed Spirituality translated and published under the auspices of the Dutch Reformed Translation Society.
Mr.
Wigger is an elder in the Protestant Reformed Church of Hudsonville, Michigan.
Evangelism Activities
This past month members of the Evangelism Committee of the Randolph, WI PRC were able to host a booth at the Alto Fair. Pamphlets, books, and tapes were made available to fair goers in an effort to make them more aware of the Reformed distinctives and Randolph PRC. Related to that effort, in August Randolph will also be starting a series of community mailings this fall, intending to mail about three a year. This was intended to be yet another way in which members of Randolph could show their community that they do stand for the truth of Gods Word. The congregation was also encouraged to talk to their neighbors after the first mailing appeared in their mailboxes, to see if they had any questions about it.
A summer singspiration sponsored by the Evangelism Society of First PRC in Grand Rapids, MI was held Sunday evening, August 8, at First Church. It was hoped that, since it was summertime, many young children would be able to attend. Anticipating this, Firsts Evangelism Society planned several songs for younger children. There was an offering for the evangelism work of First, and a light lunch was served before the program. What a joyful way to bring a Lords Day to a close with praise to God with instruments and voices.
Members of PR congregations around the Chicago, IL area were reminded in early August that the Reformed Witness Hour program had changed radio stations. Beginning on August 8, the program began to be heard on Sunday mornings, 8:30 a.m., on radio station WAIT. Congregation members were asked to let their friends, family, and acquaintances know of the change. Peace PRC in Lansing, IL even encouraged their members to distribute flyers that included a listing of the programs for August to anyone they thought might be interested in listening to the messages.
Mission Activities
In a recent letter from Mrs. Phyllis Bekkering, wife of missionary Rev. W. Bekkering, serving our churches in Ghana, West Africa, we read that our missionaries there are having a difficult time right now. The mission is losing some of its members. Mrs. Bekkering continues her letter by saying, Whether that is good or bad we leave in Gods hands. The missionaries labor to preach the Word to His people and His people are fed. God, who gives us strength to continue our work here, is working His good work. We trust in His wisdom in all things, which is a great comfort when times are difficult. Remember our churches work in Ghana in your prayers.
When the committee of Rev. G. Eriks and Mr. Dave Poortenga, from the Loveland, CO PRC, the calling church for our denominations mission work in Spokane, WA and the Covenant of Grace PR Fellowship there, were in Spokane recently, they heard the confessions of faith of Christopher Miersma, son of missionary Rev. T. and Janice Miersma, and Aaron and Deb Edwards, a young couple who have been part of the group for over a year and a half, on behalf of the Loveland consistory. All three gave a good confession of their belief in Christ as their Savior, as well as to their agreement with the doctrines and practices of the PRC. With thanksgiving to God, the confessions, as well as the adult baptism of Aaron Edwards, took place on Sunday, August 15. We rejoice in this evidence of growth in Spokane.
Missionary Rev. J. Mahtani, his wife Esther, and part of their family were able to spend about two weeks, from August 9-23, in Fayetteville, N.C. with the members of the Protestant Reformed Fellowship there. This was scheduled to be a working vacation in order to fulfill Rev. Mahtanis long overdue visit to the saints there. For vacation time, those two weeks included spending time with families living in the area, relaxing on the beach, and time for the family to rest and reflect before another busy study season. The working part of the two weeks was to include visiting with the saints there, spending time pursuing past contacts in the area, besides preaching for two Lords Days for the Fellowship and its members.
Congregation Activities
Christian Fellowship members of the Hull, Iowa PRC were invited to join together at Rock Rapids pool on August 11. Swimming was from 7-9 p.m., with lunch served afterwards in the park.
Members of the Adult Fellowship of Hope PRC in Redlands, CA were asked to reserve August 14 for a beach day for the whole family. Members of Hope were invited to come any time during the day, and the committee would provide dinner.
The Mens Choral Group of the Loveland, CO PRC presented a program on August 8 after their evening service. Besides choral singing, there were several special numbers.
Minister Activities
From a trio of Rev. W. Bruinsma, Rev. D. Kleyn, and Rev. J. Slopsema, the congregation of First PRC in Edmonton, AB, Canada extended a call to Rev. Kleyn to serve as their next pastor.
Text Author page
Genesis 13:14-18 JAS 458
Psalm 1:6 RGM 386
Psalm 4:5-7 RGM 74
Psalm 42:5 JAS 266
Psalm 55:22 RVO 98
Psalm 71:18 MBL 110
Psalm 146:3-5 JAS 146
Proverbs 31:27, 28 WGB 257
Haggai RHH 114
Haggai 1:1, 2 RHH 157
Haggai 1:2-4 RHH 188
Haggai 1:3-6 RHH 206
Haggai 1:7-11 RHH 227
Haggai 1:9-12 RHH 259
Haggai 1:13-15 RHH 273
Haggai 2:1-3 RHH 333
Haggai 2:3-7 RHH 354
Zechariah 4:6 RVO 410
Matthew 3:13-17 RVO 194
Matthew 7:12 JAS 338
Matthew 28:5, 6 MVW 290
Luke 2:7 MVW 122
John 10:16 RGM 482
Acts 8:3, 4 RGM 218
Romans 5:1 MVW 434
Romans 8:30 b SRK 331
II Corinthians 7:10 JAS 50
Galatians 5:6 MVW 242
Ephesians 4:1-3 RVO 2
Ephesians 4:7, 8 RVO 170
Ephesians 4:11-13 RVO 314
III John 11 JAS 362
Books Reviewed
Title Author Reviewer page
Case for Covenantal
Christianity at the Religious Roundtable:
Companion to the Current
Current Justification Controversy O.
P. Robertson DJE 320
Gods Renaissance Man: The Life and Work of
Irish Puritans:
James Ussher and the
Justification
F. Turretin
DJE 495
Martin Luther: The
Christian Between
Measuring the Music:
Another Look at the
Not Reformed at All:
Medievalism
Path of True Godliness, The Willem Teellinck DJE
495
Postmillennialism:
An Eschatology
Praying Together for True Revival J. Edwards
DJE 494
Presbyterian Doctrine of Children
Prophet and His Message: Reading Old Testament
Redeeming Pop Culture:
Tenth Presbyterian Church of
Upon This Rock
D. Doezema
DJE 8
Wesley and Men Who Followed
I. Murray
DJE 123
Westminster Confession of Faith for
When Thou Sittest in Thine House:
Why I Left the Contemporary Christian Music Movement:
Title Index
Title Author page
Account of a Fallen Seminary
Against Gospel Services
AT
416
Aging
MBL 110
All Creatures Created for the Service of Man JM 235
All the Land to You and Your Seed JAS 458
And He Builded a City
AK
404
And Then Theres the Seventh
Anon. No Longer
LR
150
Apostolicity of the Church (1), The JAL 490
Appalling Apostasy in the Netherlands DJE
76
Ashamed DHK 397
Assurance for All the Children
DJE
196
Assuring Spirit, The
DJE 460
Athens, Here We Come!
MCD 449
Australian Muslims Take Pastors to
Availing of Faith, The
MVW 242
Beginning of our Glorification, The SRK 331
Being, Shape, Form, and Several Offices
Best Criticism of the Error
CWB 395
Bible Versions
CW
393
Blessed Way of the Righteous, The RGM 386
Build Your Own Theology
GVB 113
Burger King Religion Have It Your Way! GVB 202
Calvin on Justification
MS
36
Calvin the Preacher RHH 42
Calvins Doctrine of Predestination CJT 44
Calvins Doctrine of the Christian Life DJE
34
Calvins Doctrine of the Christian Life (concl.) DJE
54
Cast Down Soul, The
JAS 266
Casting Our Burdens on the Lord RVO 998
Catholicity of the Church, The
JAL
475
Certain Assurance
DJE 173
Christian Story and the Christian School (5), The AL
58
Closer to Home
KK
400
Come, See the Place!
MVW 290
Committing the Truth to Faithful Men (1)
RDD 81
Committing the Truth to Faithful Men (2)
RDD 107
Confessional Certainty
DJE 220
Covenant Concept (1), The
HH
105
Covenant Concept (2), The
HH
129
Covenantal Universalism:
New Form of
Covenantal Universalism:
New Form of
Covenant Universalism:
New Form of
Criticism of an Excellent Translation RWH 439
Davids Joy of Gratitude RGM 74
Dealing with Change
JK
246
Debate: Is
the Doctrine
Defense of the Presbyterian Doctrine
Delight Over Assurance
AJB 295
Difficult and Dangerous Area
TS
417
Domestic Missions Update
DD
379
Eastern Ideas (3)
CK
56
Eastern Ideas (4)
CK
150
Eastern Ideas (5)
CK
252
Ecclesiology: The
Study of the Church JAL
370
Editorship of the Standard Bearer EC 342
Educating the Church
LG
416
Election and Installation of Deacons (7) DJK
14
Election and Reprobation in the Sphere
Emphasis on Responsibility
HDB 79
Evangelism in the Established Church (1)
JLK
472
Faith Is Assurance DJE 436
Faith Is Assurance:
Scripture
DJE 268
Faith Is Assurance:
The Reformation Gospel
DJE 340
Faithful Translation, A
TH
394
Faithfully Afflicted DK 344
Faiths Assurance
DJE 244
Finally
DJE 487
Foreign Missions: Through the Eyes of our Missionaries RJS
376
Freedom of Religion Within Limits GVB
112
Fundamental Work of the Deacons (1), The DJK 116
Fundamental Work of the Deacons (2), The DJK 179
Fundamental Work of the Deacons (3), The DJK 275
Fundamental Work of the Deacons (4), The DJK 421
Gibsons Passion Romish to the Core
KK
346
Gift of Assurance, The
DJE 484
Gift of Pastors, The
RVO 314
Gift of Peace, The
MVW 434
Godly Sorrow
JAS 50
Gods Command to Mothers WGB
257
Gods Glorious Work of Sanctification JAL
19
Gods Love and Hatred Toward Men (1)
DK
398
Gods Love and Hatred Toward Men (2)
DK
445
Golden Rule, The
JAS 338
Haggai: Rebuilding
the Church
RHH 114
Haggai: Rebuilding
the Church (2)
RHH 157
Haggai: Rebuilding
the Church (3)
RHH 188
Haggai: Rebuilding
the Church (4)
RHH 206
Haggai: Rebuilding
the Church (5)
RHH 227
Haggai: Rebuilding
the Church (6)
RHH 259
Haggai: Rebuilding
the Church (7)
RHH 333
Haggai: Rebuilding
the Church (8)
RHH 273
Haggai: Rebuilding
the Church (9)
RHH 354
Handmaidens of Jehovah (1)
RJS
183
Handmaidens of Jehovah (2)
RJS
229
Happiness of Those Whose Hope Is in the Lord JAS
146
Hard Stands
WJG 78
Hasty Fruit Before Summer, The AK 281
Hell hath No Fury Like
KK 176
High Moral Ground?, The
GVB 425
Humanism vs. Protestant Reformed Teachers:
Imitate That Which Is Good
JAS 362
In Favor of the Vernacular
SVW 299
Installation of New Seminary Professor DHK
87
Intermediate State, The
DJE 210
Irreverent Modern Versions
RK
343
Islam (1) CK 351
Islam (1) cont.
CK
467
Jackson Case, The GVB 160
Jacobus Arminius and Arminianism (3) HCH
10
John Calvins Institutes of the Christian
Religion DK
32
John Wesley (1)
HCH 426
John Wesley (2)
HCH 469
KJV, Still the Best
MB 394
Labor Union Membership
Labor Union Membership
Laid in a Manger
MVW 122
Letter from Seminary
RDD 86
Life of John Calvin, Pastor and Teacher BLG
29
Little Bit of History
HK
325
Love for the Church (2)
DK
90
Love for the Church (3)
DK
155
Lying
JLR 9
Male and Female Created He Them AK 465
Marriage Is it Necessary? GVB
247
Marriage Amendment and Christian Beliefs GVB 368
Marrow Men (1), The
HCH 204
Marrow Men (2), The
HCH 249
Marrow Men (3), The
HCH 329
Marrow Men (4), The
HCH 348
Massachusetts Marriage Amendment KK
347
Meantime, Just to the North of US KK 65
Mission Preaching
Moise Amyraut and Amyraldianism (1)
HCH 92
Moise Amyraut and Amyraldianism (2)
HCH 132
More on Gospel Services
HCH 295
More on Responsibility
HDB 175
More on Therapeutic Cloning: Its Murder
KK
178
Morning Glories
MCD 164
Necessary Baptism, A
RVO 194
Needed: A
Book on Reformed Worldview
VW
226
New Editor Sought DJE 7
New RFPA Book on Worship
DJE
367
New Work on New Testament History, A
DJE 8
Nitrogen Cycle: Upheld
and Governed
Not by Human Might, But by Gods Spirit RVO 410
Nurturing Godliness in Missions JK 283
Oh Canada!
KK
399
On Target
CF
80
On the Day of His Birth
AK
356
One Holy Church, One Covenant of Grace
JAL 419
Organic Unity of the Church, The JAL 402
Our Mission Work in the Philippines DK
139
Passion of Christ A Movie Review, The GVB 278
Passion of the Christ:
Are We There? MCD 326
Perseverance of the Saints, The
SRK 255
Pluralism of the Elitists, The KK
178
Pop Treatment of Culture, A
FO
226
Precious Assurance DJE 148
Presbyterian Case for the Baptist Rejection
Preservation of the Saints
SRK 185
Progress in Pittsburgh
RK
68
Reflections on Synodical Decisions GVB 447
Reform of Geneva, The
SRK 39
Reformed Churches of South Africa, The
SLC
300
Reformed Churches of South Africa, The
SLC
322
Reformed Churches of South Africa, The
SLC
372
Remember the Sabbath Day to Keep It Holy GVB 127
Remembering the Schism of 1953 DJE 101
Reproach DHK 182
Reward of Grace, The
JAL 135
Rock Against the Storm, A
AS
442
Sanctification and Good Works
JAL
88
Signs of the Times GVB 112
Silence Concerning Murray on Wesley in UK JS
270
Still More on Lying
RWH 104
Sunday Evening Gospel Service, The AS
199
Superb Series
CHR 417
Synod 2004, Hull, Iowa
DJE 413
Thanksgiving to Whom?
GVB 159
Theologians Debate Gods Foreknowledge
GVB 367
Theories of Atonement
GVB 424
They Preached Christ Everywhere RGM 218
Those Other Sheep RGM 482
Thou Renewest the Face of the Earth AK
162
Time of Self-examination (2)
GVB 17
Two Different Covenants,
Two Different Covenants,
Two Different Covenants,
258th Synod of the RCUS
GVB 448
2003 Annual RFPA Secretarys Report DL
83
2004 Synod of the PRC
DJE 393
Unity (1) CM 137
Unity (2), The
CM 443
Upholding the KJV PS
440
Walk Worthy of Our Calling, A
RVO 2
Were You There?
PS
417
Wesley and Murray, Who Follows DJE 123
What About the Sixth Commandment? GVB
128
What Is Marriage? GVB 463
What Think Ye of the Christ?
Wheaton College Slates Historic Dance GVB
161
When Ball Becomes Baal
KK
492
Whence the Diversity Within the Church
RVO 170
Where This Is All Heading
KK
492
Who Is to Blame for the Scandal
Why a Reformed Christian May Not Attend
Working Mothers
WGB 305
Subject Index
Subject Title
Author page
ADVENT
Laid in a Manger MVW 122
AFFLICTIONS
Faithfully Afflicted DK 344
ALMS
Fundamental Work of the Deacons (2), The
DJK 179
Fundamental Work of the Deacons (4), The
DJK 421
AMILLENNIALISM
Difficult and Dangerous Area TS 417
AMYRALDIANISM
Moise Amyraut and Amyraldianism (1)
HCH 92
Moise Amyraut and Amyraldianism (2)
HCH 132
APOSTASY
Appalling Apostasy in the Netherlands DJE 76
ARMINIUS, JACOBUS
Jacobus Arminius and Arminianism (3) HCH 10
ASSURANCE
Assurance for All the Children
DJE 196
Assuring Spirit, The
DJE 460
Certain Assurance DJE 173
Confessional Certainty
DJE 220
Delight Over Assurance
AJB 295
Faith Is Assurance DJE 436
Faith Is Assurance: Scripture
DJE
268
Faith Is Assurance: The Reformation
Gospel DJE 340
Faiths Assurance DJE 244
Gift of Assurance, The
DJE 484
Precious Assurance DJE 148
ATONEMENT
Theories of Atonement
GVB 424
BAPTISM
Presbyterian Case for the Baptist Rejection
BIBLE TRANSLATIONS/VERSIONS
Bible Versions
CW
393
Irreverent Modern Versions RK 343
BIRTHDAYS
On the Day of His Birth
AK
356
CALLING
Walk Worthy of Our Calling, A
RVO 2
CALVIN, JOHN
Calvin on Justification
MS
36
Calvin the Preacher RHH 42
Calvins Doctrine of Predestination
CJT 44
Calvins Doctrine of the Christian Life DJE 34
Calvins Doctrine of the Christian Life (concl.)
DJE 54
Election and Reprobation in the Sphere
John Calvins Institutes of the Christian Religion DK
32
Life of John Calvin, Pastor and Teacher BLG 29
On Target
CF
80
Reform of Geneva, The
SRK 39
Special Issue
25
CANONS OF DORDRECHT
Jacobus Arminius and Arminianism (3) HCH 10
CATHOLICISM
Gibsons Passion Romish to the Core
KK
346
CHRIST, BAPTISM OF
Necessary Baptism, A
RVO 194
CHRIST, DEITY OF
What Think Ye of the Christ?
CHRIST, SUFFERING OF
Passion of the Christ: Are We There? MCD
326
CHRISTIAN EDUCATION
Humanism vs. Protestant Reformed Teachers:
CHRISTIAN LIFE
Calvins Doctrine of the Christian Life DJE 34
Calvins Doctrine of the Christian Life (concl.)
DJE 54
CHRISTIAN SCHOOLS
Christian Story and
Two Different Covenants,
Two Different Covenants,
Two Different Covenants,
CHURCH
Apostolicity of the Church (1)
JAL 490
Ecclesiology: The Study of the Church JAL
370
Educating the Church
LG
416
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church
RHH 114
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (2) RHH 157
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (3) RHH 188
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (4) RHH 206
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (5) RHH 227
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (6) RHH 259
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (7) RHH 333
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (8) RHH 273
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (9) RHH 354
Love for the Church (2)
DK
90
Love for the Church (3)
DK
155
Whence the Diversity Within the Church
RVO 170
CHURCH HISTORY
Reformed Churches of South Africa, The
SLC 300
Reformed Churches of South Africa, The
SLC 322
Reformed Churches of South Africa, The
SLC 372
CHURCH MEMBERSHIP
Reader Asks
BO
395
CHURCH UNITY
One Holy Church, One Covenant of Grace
JAL 419
Organic Unity of the Church, The
JAL 402
CITY LIFE
And He Builded a City
AK
404
CLONING
More on Therapeutic Cloning: Its
Murder
KK
178
COMFORT
Come, See the Place!
MVW 290
COMMON GRACE
Debate: Is the Doctrine
of Common Grace Reformed?, The
GVB 66
Gods Love and Hatred Toward Men (2)
DK
445
Hard Stands
WJG 78
CONFESSION OF FAITH
Progress in Pittsburgh
RK
68
COVENANT
Covenant Concept (1), The HH 105
Covenant Concept (2), The HH 129
Covenantal Universalism: New Form of
Covenantal Universalism: New Form of
Two Different Covenants,
Two Different Covenants,
Two Different Covenants,
COVENANT OF GRACE
Remembering the Schism of 1953
DJE 101
CREATION
All Creatures Created for the Service of Man
JM
235
Being, Shape, Form, and Several Offices
CULTURE
Athens, Here We Come!
MCD 449
Pop Treatment of Culture, A FO 226
DANCING
Wheaton College Slates Historic Dance GVB 161
DEACONS
Election and Installation of Deacons (7) DJK 14
Fundamental Work of the Deacons (1), The
DJK 116
Fundamental Work of the Deacons (2), The
DJK 179
Fundamental Work of the Deacons (3), The
DJK 275
Fundamental Work of the Deacons (4), The
DJK 421
DEATH
Aging MBL 110
DOMESTIC MISSIONS
Domestic Missions Update DD 379
EASTERN THOUGHT
Eastern Ideas (3) CK 56
Eastern Ideas (4) CK 150
Eastern Ideas (5) CK 252
ECCLESIOLOGY
Apostolicity of the Church JAL 490
Ecclesiology: The Study of the Church JAL
370
ELECTION
Election and Reprobation in the Sphere
END TIMES
Eastern Ideas (5) CK 252
Signs of the Times GVB 112
ESCHATOLOGY
Intermediate State, The
DJE 210
EVANGELISM
Against Gospel Services
AT
416
Evangelism in the Established Church (1)
JLK 470
FAITH
Availing of Faith, The
MVW 242
Faith Is Assurance DJE 436
Faith Is Assurance: Scripture
DJE
268
Faith Is Assurance: The Reformation
Gospel DJE 340
Faiths Assurance DJE 244
FAITHFULNESS
Committing the Truth to Faithful Men (1)
RDD 81
Committing the Truth to Faithful Men (2)
RDD 107
FEMINISM
Hell hath No Fury Like
KK
176
FOREIGN MISSIONS
Foreign Missions: Through the Eyes
FOREKNOWLEDGE
Theologians Debate Gods Foreknowledge
GVB 367
GAY MARRIAGES
Closer to Home KK 400
GODLINESS
Nurturing Godliness in Missions
JK
283
GOODNESS
Sanctification and Good Works
JAL 88
GRACE
Reward of Grace, The
JAL 135
HAGGAI
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church
RHH 114
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (2) RHH 157
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (3) RHH 188
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (4) RHH 206
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (5) RHH 227
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (6) RHH 259
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (7) RHH 333
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (8) RHH 273
Haggai: Rebuilding the Church (9) RHH 354
HANNAH
Handmaidens of Jehovah (1) RJS 183
HAPPINESS
Happiness of Those Whose Hope Is
HATE CRIMES
Australian Muslims Take Pastors
Meantime, Just to the North of US
KK
65
Where This Is All Heading KK 492
HATRED OF GOD
Gods Love and Hatred Toward Men (1)
DK
398
Gods Love and Hatred Toward Men (2)
DK
445
HERETICS
Jacobus Arminius and Arminianism (3) HCH 10
John Wesley (1) HCH 426
John Wesley (2) HCH 467
Marrow Men (1), The
HCH 204
Marrow Men (2), The
HCH 249
HERETICS (cont.)
Marrow Men (3), The
HCH 329
Marrow Men (4), The
HCH 348
Moise Amyraut and Amyraldianism (1)
HCH 92
Moise Amyraut and Amyraldianism (2)
HCH 132
Wesley and Murray, Who Follows
DJE 123
HISTORY OF PRC
Remembering the Schism of 1953
DJE 101
HOMOSEXUALITY
And Then Theres the Seventh
Oh Canada!
KK
399
HUMANISM
Humanism vs. Protestant Reformed Teachers:
IMITATION
Imitate That Which is Good JAS 362
INFANT BAPTISM
Presbyterian Case for the Baptist Rejection
INTERMEDIATE STATE
Intermediate State, The
DJE 210
ISLAM
Islam (1) CK 351
Islam (1) cont.
CK
475
JUSTIFICATION
Calvin on Justification
MS
36
258th Synod of the RCUS
GVB 448
KING JAMES VERSION
Criticism of an Excellent Translation
RWH 439
Faithful Translation, A
TH
394
In Favor of the Vernacular
SVW 299
KJV, Still the Best MB 394
Rock Against the Storm, A AS 442
Upholding the KJV PS
440
LABOR UNIONS
Labor Union Membership
Labor Union Membership
LAY PREACHING
They Preached Christ Everywhere
RGM 218
LOVE OF GOD
Gods Love and Hatred Toward Men (1)
DK
398
Gods Love and Hatred Toward Men (2)
DK
445
LYING
Lying JLR 9
Still More on Lying
RWH 104
MARRIAGE
Male and Female Created He Them
AK
465
Marriage Is it Necessary? GVB 247
Marriage Amendment and Christian Beliefs
GVB 368
Massachusetts Marriage Amendment KK 347
What Is Marriage? GVB 463
MARROWMEN
Marrow Men (1), The
HCH 204
Marrow Men (2), The
HCH 249
Marrow Men (3), The
HCH 329
Marrow Men (4), The
HCH 348
MARY
Handmaidens of Jehovah (1) RJS 183
MISSIONS
Domestic Missions Update DD 379
Foreign Missions: Through the Eyes
Mission Preaching
More on Gospel Services
HCH 295
More on Responsibility
HDB 175
Nurturing Godliness in Missions
JK
283
Our Mission work in the Philippines
DK
139
Progress in Pittsburgh
RK
68
Sunday Evening Gospel Service, The
AS
199
MORALITY
High Moral Ground?, The
GVB 425
MOTHERS
Gods Command to Mothers WGB 257
Handmaidens of Jehovah (2) RJS 229
Working Mothers WGB 305
MOVIES
Gibsons Passion Romish to the Core
KK
346
Passion of Christ A Movie Review, The
GVB 278
Why a Reformed Christian May Not Attend
MURRAY, IAN
Silence Concerning Murray on Wesley in UK
JS
270
Wesley and Murray, Who Follows
DJE 123
MYSTICISM
Eastern Ideas (4) CK 150
NEW AGE MOVEMENT
Eastern Ideas (3) CK 56
NEW YEAR
Happiness of Those Whose Hope Is
OFFICEBEARERS
Election and Installation of Deacons (7) DJK 14
ORDO SALUTIS
Beginning of our Glorification, The
SRK 331
PASSION OF CHRIST
Gibsons Passion Romish to the Core
KK
346
Passion of Christ A Movie Review, The
GVB 278
Passion of the Christ: Are We There? MCD
326
Why a Reformed Christian May Not Attend
PASTORS
Gift of Pastors, The
RVO 314
PEACE
Gift of Peace, The MVW 434
PEDOPHILIA
Jackson Case, The GVB 160
PERSECUTION
Australian Muslims Take Pastors
PERSEVERANCE
Perseverance of the Saints, The
SRK 255
PRAYER
Love for the Church (3)
DK
155
PRE-SYNODICAL SERMON
Not by Human Might, But by Gods Spirit
RVO 410
PREACHER
Calvin the Preacher RHH 42
PREACHING
Committing the Truth to Faithful Men (1)
RDD 81
Committing the Truth to Faithful Men (2)
RDD 107
Mission Preaching
More on Gospel Services
HCH 295
PREDESTINATION
Calvins Doctrine of Predestination
CJT 44
PRESERVATION
Preservation of the Saints
SRK 185
PROVIDENCE
All Creatures Created for the Service of Man
JM
235
Being, Shape, Form, and Several Offices
Nitrogen Cycle: Upheld and Governed
PUBLICATIONS
New RFPA Book on Worship
DJE 367
New Work on New Testament History, A
DJE 8
REFORMATION
Reform of Geneva, The
SRK 39
REFORMED FAITH
John Calvins Institutes of the Christian Religion DK
32
REFORMED FREE PUBLISHING ASSOCIATION
2003 Annual RFPA Secretarys Report DL 83
REFORMED WORLDVIEW
Needed: A Book on Reformed Worldview
VW
226
RELIGIOUS FREEDOM
Freedom of Religion Within Limits GVB 112
REPROACH
Reproach DHK
182
REPROBATION
Election and Reprobation in the Sphere
RESPONSIBILITY
Emphasis on Responsibility HDB 79
RESURRECTION
Come, See the Place
MVW 290
ROME
Who Is to Blame for the Scandal
SABBATH OBSERVANCE
Remember the Sabbath Day to Keep it Holy
GVB 127
When Ball Becomes Baal
KK
493
SANCTIFICATION
Gods Glorious Work of Sanctification JAL 19
Sanctification and Good Works
JAL 88
SEASONS
Hasty Fruit Before Summer, The
AK
281
Thou Renewest the Face of the Earth
AK
162
SEVENTH COMMANDMENT
And Then Theres the Seventh
SHAME
Ashamed DHK
397
SIXTH COMMANDMENT
What About the Sixth Commandment? GVB 128
SMOKING
Time of Self-examination (2) GVB 128
SORROW
Godly Sorrow
JAS
50
SOUTH AFRICA
Reformed Churches of South Africa, The
SLC 300
Reformed Churches of South Africa, The
SLC 322
Reformed Churches of South Africa, The
SLC 372
SPECIAL ISSUE
25
SPIRITUAL MATURITY
Morning Glories MCD 164
SPORTS
When Ball Becomes Baal
KK
493
STANDARD BEARER
Editorship of the Standard Bearer
EC
342
Finally DJE 487
New Editor Sought DJE 7
SYNOD
Synod 2004, Hull, Iowa
DJE 413
2004 Synod of the PRC
DJE 393
TEACHERS
Humanism vs. Protestant Reformed Teachers:
No R&R (3)
RJD 12
THANKSGIVING
Davids Joy of Gratitude
RGM 74
Thanksgiving to Whom?
GVB 159
TOLERANCE
Pluralism of the Elitists, The KK 178
TRUTH
Unity (2), The
CM 443
UNITY OF CHURCH
Dealing with Change
JK
246
Unity (1) CM
137
Walk Worthy of Our Calling, A
RVO 2
UNIVERSALISM
Account of a Fallen Seminary
Best Criticism of the Error CWB 395
Covenantal Universalism: New Form of
Covenantal Universalism: New Form of
Covenantal Universalism: New Form of
Superb Series
CHR 417
Were You There? PS
417
WESLEY, JOHN
John Wesley (1) HCH 426
John Wesley (2) HCH 467
Wesley and Murray, Who Follows
DJE 123
WINGHAM PRC
Little Bit of History, A
HK
325
WITNESSING
Against Gospel Services
AT
416
WOMEN IN OFFICE
Reflections on Synodical Decisions
GVB 447
WORD STUDIES
Ashamed DHK
397
Reproach DHK
182
WORKING MOTHERS
Working Mothers WGB 305
WORLDVIEW
Needed: A Book on Reformed Worldview
VW
226
WORSHIP
Burger King Religion Have It Your Way!
GVB 202
Sunday Evening Gospel Service, The
AS
199
LECTURE
Speaker:
Prof. David J. Engelsma
Title:
The Reformed Worldview
(a follow-up of the
Date/Time:
Friday, October 8, 2004, 7:30 p.m.
Location:
Grace Community Church,
3500 New Holland,
Hudsonville, MI
NOTICE!!!
Our pastor, Rev. Steven
Houck, will be completing his 25th year of service as a
minister in our denomination this September, the Lord willing. An evening of thanksgiving to God for Pastor
Houcks faithful work among us is planned for Sunday, October 10, at 7:30 p.m.
following the evening worship service. You
are invited to join us at Peace PRC in Lansing, IL for this joyous occasion.
Peace PRC
Bill DeJong, Clerk
Garry Eriks, Vice President
World and Life View
September 24 & 25, 2004 in
Hull, IA
Sponsored by the Christian
Friday, September 24 at 7:30 p.m.
Lecture
at the chapel in Dordt College
Sioux Center, IA
Speaker: Prof.
David Engelsma
Reformed Worldview of
Particular Grace
Saturday, September 25
Events held at Hull PRC
9:30 a.m.
Speech by Prof. Syd
Hielema,
Professor of theology at Dordt
College,
giving Dordts position on
their world/life view.
Lecture by Prof.
David Engelsma
Flawed & Fatal
Worldview of Common Grace
LunchProvided by
the
Hull Christian Fellowship
Society.
Symposium/Debate
Prof. Engelsma, Prof. Hielema
2004
FALL REFORMATION LECTURE
Rev. Charles Terpstra
will speak on
Solo Christo
Principles of the Reformation:
#2 Salvation by
Christ Alone!
Friday, October 29, 2004
7:30 p.m.
Sponsored by
First Holland PRC
Evangelism Committee
3641 104th Ave.
Zeeland, MI 49464
Come, bring a friend;
refreshments will be served